Can an infraction be classified as a Game Play Error if the judge believes it was done intentionally?

In the context of the Judge Infraction Procedure Guide, a Game Play Error is specifically associated with mistakes made during the course of a game that are unintentional. These errors typically occur as a result of misunderstanding the game rules or making an oversight without any intent to breach them. By definition, Game Play Errors are not meant to encompass actions that are deliberate or intentional.

When a judge determines that an action was taken with intent, it shifts the classification away from a Game Play Error to another category of infraction, such as Cheating. This distinction is crucial because the consequences for intentional infractions are generally more severe, reflecting the seriousness of knowingly breaking the rules. The rationale is that players are expected to adhere to the rules fairly, and intentional infractions undermine the integrity of the game.

The perspective on intent, and its separation from unintentional mistakes, underscores the importance of accurately assessing a situation. It helps ensure that players are held accountable for their conduct in a manner that aligns with the principles of fair play in Magic: The Gathering.