Can the penalty for Drawing Extra Cards be downgraded?

The correct answer is that the penalty for Drawing Extra Cards can indeed be downgraded under specific circumstances. When all players at the table are aware of the identity of the extra card drawn, it indicates that there was likely no significant impact on the game state, allowing for the possibility of a downgraded penalty.

In such cases, since the knowledge of the extra card does not confer an unfair advantage and the game can continue without disruption, the judge may determine that a Warning or other less severe penalty is appropriate instead of the standard Game Loss.

Understanding this nuance is essential in evaluating how infractions are assessed during gameplay, and it highlights the importance of context and player awareness in penalization decisions. In scenarios where the information is not clear-cut or if players were unaware, harsher penalties may be warranted to maintain the integrity of the game.